Wanted: Bold Steps and Rule of Law

  • Date : 07/23/2015
Wanted: Bold Steps and Rule of Law

Less than two months after the PRI gained a marginal victory in Mexico’s midterm elections, the administration of Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto has been hit by two stinging setbacks.

First was the humiliating escape of Joaquín “El Chapo” Guzman, the head of the infamous Sinaloa Cartel, and soon after was the energy reform’s less than stellar first bidding round. All is not lost on either front, but moving forward will require a dramatic change of tone and direction on security measures, and serious recalibration on the energy side.

On July 11, El Chapo slipped through a tunnel in his maximum-security cell and emerged as a free man some 1.5 kilometers away. The shocking escape rocked the country (and the world) and underscored the extent to which corruption permeates even the top and supposedly most secure parts of Mexico’s security establishment. It also brings to light the issue of why El Chapo was sitting in that prison in the first place. Especially as U.S. officials had formally filed an extradition request less than three weeks before his escape.

Carin Zissis’ piece for Americas Society / Council of the Americas’ (where I serve as a board member) highlights how extradition may be the Mexican government’s most effective tool for fighting the cartels. Yet, since El Chapo’s capture eighteen months ago, the bilateral cooperation on this front has waned. Of course, the United States and Mexico’s security relationship extends well beyond this singular issue. That said, the escape threatens to put our bi-lateral collaboration on less certain ground, as Alfredo Corchado explains in his piece in the Dallas Morning News.

As the nation reeled from El Chapo’s disappearing act, the government turned in an underwhelming performance in the country’s first energy auction. July 14 marked the bidding day for fourteen shallow water blocks up for exploration, and while interest among major energy companies had been high in the lead-up, only six of the blocks received any bids at all. Of these, two fields received bids that surpassed the government’s minimum fiscal requirements. This meant that only two fields were assigned (a 14 percent success rate), falling short of the government’s own 30 to 50 percent benchmark for measuring success.

The reasons behind this lackluster performance are likely a combination of low global oil pricesconcern over elements of the government’s production-sharing contracts, the fields’ small size, and geological considerations. On a positive note, the bidding round itself was highly transparent and efficient and the actual process of running a tender went off without a hitch. The government will certainly want to repeat this smooth process for future rounds, but it will need to aggressively review all commercial terms to make sure they are as attractive as possible for future investors.

Since El Chapo’s quick apprehension and extradition is unlikely, what the government should do is immediately shift toward a serious, long-term and sustained commitment to building the country’s rule of law. But even bold steps and a strong policy agenda may very well be too little too late for regaining Mexicans’ frayed trust in their government, but are absolutely critical to maintaining investor confidence going forward. At this point this is not only the best path, but the only one worth pursuing.

I hope you’ll stay connected and in touch with me on LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter  for more news from Mexico.  And, if I can assist you or your team here at White & Case in Mexico City or through Vianovo Ventures, simply call.


Antonio Garza

Our History in Mexico

White & Case may be headquartered in the United States, but our history and track record in Mexico makes us “unparalleled” with a “depth of talent and strong expertise” across a wide range of industry sectors and practices.  Learn more about our history and presence in Mexico online here.

Spotlight on Juan Antonio Martín

Our team in Mexico City is led by executive partner Juan Antonio Martín, who is widely recognized as one of the top 10 capital markets and banking and finance lawyers in Mexico. You can learn more about his depth of experience and stellar reputation online here.

Energy Updates

To navigate the evolving situation on the ground in Mexico when it comes to energy reforms and its impact on foreign opportunities and investment, be sure to follow White & Case’s energy section.

We’re also fortunate to have Daniel Sanchez as a partner in our Mexico City office. His work in the energy, infrastructure and project finance fields is extensive and impressive. Learn more about Daniel, here.

Texas Exes Leadership

July marks my first month as president of the Texas Exes, the alumni association for The University of Texas at Austin. I wanted to share with you Texas Exes CEO Leslie Cedar’s note, as well as my own thoughts on the university.


  • Mexico: Pushing Past Pessimism
    With drug kingpin El Chapo’s escape from a maximum-security prison and a disappointing first-round energy auction, Mexico’s summer was far from idyllic.
  • A Brief Respite
    After several challenging months, Mexico finally has a bit of positive news. Last week marked the second bidding phase in Round 1 of the country’s energy reform, and unlike the first stage, this auction was widely deemed a success. The government awarded three of the five shallow-water production fields in a transparent and efficient process. […]
  • Mexico’s Midterm, Washington’s Gridlock
    Just over a week ago, Mexican voters headed to the polls to cast their votes...